Morning Digest: Why we won't know the winner of New York's mayoral primaries for weeks

Elections news image header
Photo credit
AK-Sen AL-Gov AZ-Gov BlaineLeutkemeyer CA-Gov Elections EricAdams FL-07 GA-06 GavinNewsom ID-Gov Ipsos MattSalmon MD-Gov MO-04 MO-Sen NC-Sen NJ-Gov NM-02 OR-Gov PA-Sen PatMcCrory RichardBurr TX-AG VitoFossella WI-Gov RebeccaKleefisch AndyBiggs DKEMorningDigest valarkoosh JackCiattarelli GregSteube BrianMast PhilMurphy NealDunn WhereAreTheyNow ammonbundy jimzeigler FarleighDickinsonUniversity XochitlTorresSmall AndrewYang MarkMcCloskey NewYorkCityNYMayor MayaWiley KathrynGarcia JonBaron StatenIslandNYBoroughPresident KellyTshibaka JakeEvans CoryMills EvaGuzman OrrinHeatlie CaseyKulla RyanJohnson

The Daily Kos Elections Morning Digest is compiled by David Nir, Jeff Singer, Carolyn Fiddler, and Matt Booker, with additional contributions from David Jarman, Steve Singiser, Daniel Donner, James Lambert, David Beard, and Arjun Jaikumar.

Leading Off

● New York City, NY Mayor: A final poll from Ipsos ahead of Tuesday’s instant-runoff Democratic primary in New York City shows Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams in a strong position to secure his party’s nomination, in contrast with other recent polls that have shown one of his top rivals, former city Sanitation Commissioner Kathryn Garcia, prevailing in the end. But regardless of who’s leading, it may not be until mid-July until we know who’s actually won—more on that in a bit.

First, the new survey, which gives Adams the lead with 28% when it comes to voters’ first-choice preferences, while 2020 presidential candidate Andrew Yang edges out Garcia 20-15 for second. This is the strongest performance in some time for Yang, the one-time frontrunner, but it’s not good enough: Ipsos shows Adams beating him by a wide 56-44 spread in the seventh and final round of ranked-choice tabulations.

We’ve seen a few other polls in the last few weeks, and while they all agree that Adams is in striking distance to take the nomination, they’re not united in designating him as the undisputed frontrunner. The best recent numbers for Adams prior to Ipsos’ new data came from a Marist College poll conducted in early June that had him defeating Garcia 56-44 in the last round of tabulations.

Campaign Action

But those contrasted with Public Opinion Strategies’ survey for the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank, that found Garcia narrowly beating Adams 52-48 after ranked-choice tabulations were complete. The Democratic pollster Change Research, on behalf of a pro-Garcia super PAC, showed something very similar, with Garcia triumphing over Adams in the end by a slim 51-49 margin.

One big challenge for pollsters is that New York City will be the largest jurisdiction in America to ever hold an instant-runoff election, and no one, including the candidates, is quite sure what to expect. Vividly illustrating the terra incognita this new system is uncovering, Yang and Garcia made news over the weekend by campaigning together, an alliance that would never come about in a traditional primary.

The accord however, didn’t quite amount to a formal coalition: While Yang implored his voters, “Rank me No. 1 and then rank Kathryn Garcia No. 2,” Garcia didn’t ask her supporters to make Yang their second choice. (It’s not clear why Yang assented to such a one-sided arrangement, but Garcia says his team “absolutely knew what I was gonna say.")

The joint appearances drew a furious response from Adams, who spent his final days accusing his rivals of banding together to stop New York City from electing its second-ever Black mayor. Attorney Maya Wiley, who is also Black, had a very different response, expressing her support for ranked-choice voting and condemning Adams’ description of the alliance as a form of “voter suppression.”

No matter what, though, we’re very unlikely to know for sure who’s won the Democratic nomination until mid-July. While votes will be tabulated Tuesday after polls close at 9 PM ET for ballots cast in-person during the early voting period and on Election Day, mail-in votes will only begin to be counted on July 6 and won’t be finished until the week of July 12. The New York City Board of Elections said last month that the delay is a result of a state law that allows absentee votes to be received for up to a week after Election Day, and for voters to fix any minor errors through July 9. (Note: This item has been updated to correct the schedule for the counting of ballots.)

Ranked-choice tabulations will not occur on election night but will instead start June 29. You’ll notice that this date is long before the count of mail ballots will begin, raising the obvious question of why anyone would bother tabulating any instant-runoff scenarios before all votes are counted, since they won’t be representative of the full electorate. (If there’s a good explanation, we haven’t heard it.)

Instant-runoff voting is also being used in other city primaries, including races for comptroller, borough president, and City Council, many of which are open due to term limits. A big exception, though, is the crowded race for Manhattan district attorney: Because the post is a state-level office, the ballot measure New York City voters approved in 2019 to establish ranked-choice voting doesn’t apply, so the victor only needs a plurality to prevail.

Key elections in the rest of the state, including the Democratic primary for mayor of Buffalo, are also being conducted with plurality rules, so there’s a better chance we’ll know the winners of these races somewhat earlier, though delays in processing mail ballots still apply.

Senate

● AK-Sen: Donald Trump has endorsed former Alaska cabinet official Kelly Tshibaka in her quest to dethrone Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski, whom Trump has long despised for her insufficient fealty. Tshibaka once wrote approvingly of “conversion therapy” and hasn’t answered questions as to whether she still believes in the discredited practice herself. On a now-defunct personal blog, she also warned that the “Twilight” series of vampire books and movies “is evil and we should not read or watch it” because it “leaves us open to the enemy’s attacks.”

● MO-Sen: Attorney Mark McCloskey, who is seeking the Republican nomination for Senate, pleaded guilty late last week to a misdemeanor assault charge after he and his wife brandished firearms at a group of Black Lives Matter demonstrators. McCloskey paid a $750 fine and surrendered the weapon he pointed at protestors last year, but he said immediately after his sentencing that “I’d do it again” and quickly purchased a new rifle that he proudly showed off on social media.

Meanwhile, it looks like we can rule out Republican Rep. Blaine Leutkemeyer for this race: A spokesperson told The Missourian that the congressman “has no interest in pursuing other offices.”

● NC-Sen: File this one under endorsements you don’t want—if you’re running in a GOP primary: Retiring Sen. Richard Burr, who was one of seven Republicans who voted to convict Donald Trump at his second impeachment trial, just described former Gov. Pat McCrory as “the only one in the race that can win the general election” in next year’s Senate race in North Carolina. It’s not clear whether McCrory actually considers Burr’s comments to be a formal statement of support, but the surest sign we can look for is whether rival campaigns try to use this against him at some point.

● PA-Sen: Montgomery County Commission Chair Val Arkoosh earned an endorsement on Monday from EMILY’s List ahead of next year’s Democratic primary for this open seat. Arkoosh is the only woman running a serious campaign for Team Blue’s nomination, and that looks unlikely to change now that Reps. Madeleine Dean and Chrissy Houlahan have both taken their names out of contention.

Governors

● AL-Gov: State Auditor Jim Zeigler said Monday that he was forming an exploratory committee for a potential Republican primary campaign against Gov. Kay Ivey, but don’t mark him down as a candidate yet. Zeigler took this very action back in 2018, but he ended up staying out of that contest for governor. The auditor said later that year that he’d formed an exploratory committee for a 2020 Senate race, but he never so much as filed FEC paperwork afterwards.

● AZ-Gov: Former Rep. Matt Salmon unveiled an endorsement Monday from extremist Rep. Andy Biggs for next year’s Republican primary. It’s hardly a surprise that Biggs decided to back his predecessor in Congress: Back in 2016, Salmon issued a retirement announcement that caught almost everyone off guard except Biggs, who immediately entered the House race with Salmon’s endorsement.

● CA-Gov: Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom is out with a trio of TV ads as part of what Politico says is a $3 million opening reservation ahead of the unscheduled recall vote, and while the first spot touts his accomplishments, the other two take aim at his many far-right enemies.

One commercial begins, “The same Trump Republicans who refuse to accept the presidential election are back, passing voter suppression laws across the country. Now, they’ve set their sights on California.” As footage of the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol plays, the narrator declares, “Different tactics, same assault on democracy.”

The final ad, which is running in Spanish, makes many of the same arguments while also focusing on a figure closer to home. The narrator reminds viewers that a recall organizer named Orrin Heatlie wrote that his allies “supported tracking immigrants with microchips.”

● ID-Gov: Far-right anti-government militant Ammon Bundy, who unsuccessfully tried to file paperwork for a gubernatorial bid last month, has now officially kicked off his campaign for the GOP nomination. (For what it’s worth, that filing snafu appears to be have been resolved, since Bundy’s campaign is now listed as “Active" on the Idaho secretary of state’s website.)

Bundy is best known for leading an armed occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon in 2016, in protest of federal land management policies. While other militants were convicted of charges in relation to the occupation, Bundy himself was acquitted. Yet despite his reputation, Bundy may not be the most extreme candidate in the race, since he’s competing with Lt. Gov. Janice McGeachin for the title. Both are challenging incumbent Gov. Brad Little, who has yet to declare for re-election.

● MD-Gov: Nonprofit executive Jon Baron announced Monday that he was joining the crowded Democratic primary for this open seat. Baron, who formed an exploratory committee back in March, is a former official in the Clinton-era Department of Defense who went on to serve on boards and commissions during the Bush and Obama administrations, though this is his first run for office.

Baron later worked as vice president of Arnold Ventures, a group supported by a billionaire couple that describes its mission as “invest[ing] in evidence-based solutions that maximize opportunity and minimize injustice.” The nonprofit was in the headlines last year after it launched a program where it attempted to reduce crime by flying drones over Baltimore; Baron says he had nothing to do with this controversial initiative, which ended after six months.

● NJ-Gov: Farleigh Dickinson University has put out the first poll of New Jersey’s gubernatorial race conducted after the June 8 primary and finds Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy up 48-33 on former Republican Assemblyman Jack Ciattarelli. A poll taken by Rutgers shortly before the primary had Murphy ahead 52-26.

● OR-Gov: On Friday, Yamhill County Commissioner Casey Kulla became the first elected official to announce a campaign for the Democratic nomination for this open seat. Kulla, who works as a farmer, won his first campaign in 2018 in his county, which is located southwest of Portland.

● WI-Gov: Despite (or perhaps because of) her caginess, Wisconsin political observers have been quite certain for some time that former Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch would challenge Democratic Gov. Tony Evers next year, and new remarks she made over the weekend have them more convinced than ever. At a gathering on Saturday night, Kleefisch referred to a slew of Republican voter suppression bills and said that, with a different governor in office, “I can tell you she will sign them on day one”—with an emphasis on the word “she,” according to the Journal Times’ Adam Rogan. Still, there’s no word on when she might announce.

House

● FL-07: A trio of Florida Republican congressmen have endorsed Army veteran Cory Mills’ bid against Democratic incumbent Stephanie Murphy: Neal Dunn, Brian Mast, and Greg Steube.

● GA-06: Republican Jake Evans announced Monday that he was resigning as chair of the Georgia ethics commission ahead of what the Atlanta Journal-Constitution says is his anticipated campaign against Democratic Rep. Lucy McBath.

● MO-04: On Thursday, Cass County Commissioner Ryan Johnson became the second Republican to enter the race to succeed incumbent Vicky Hartzler, who is giving up this safely red seat in the west-central part of the state to run for the Senate. Johnson joins former state Sen. Ed Emery in what could be a crowded contest.

Johnson, who is a veteran of the Army and Coast Guard, previously worked for another Missouri Republican congressman, Sam Graves, before he helmed the dark money group Missouri Alliance for Freedom. Johnson won elected office for the first time last year when he narrowly unseated an incumbent in the primary.

● NM-02, Where Are They Now?: President Joe Biden announced Friday that he was nominating former Democratic Rep. Xochitl Torres Small for a position at the Department of Agriculture, a move that ends speculation that she could instead try to retake her old seat from Republican incumbent Yvette Herrell. The current version of the 2nd District in southern New Mexico backed Donald Trump 55-43, but Democrats could shift it to the left now that they’re in charge of the redistricting process for the first time in decades.

Attorneys General

● TX-AG: Former state Supreme Court Justice Eva Guzman announced Monday that she would take on scandal-plagued incumbent Ken Paxton in next year’s Republican primary for attorney general.

Guzman, who was the first Latina to serve on the body, joins a nomination fight that also includes Land Commissioner George P. Bush, who has a terrible relationship with the party’s nativist base. She refrained from going after Bush on his attempts to renovate the Alamo, though, and instead argued that she’s the only Paxton challenger who has the experience and credibility to hold this post.

Guzman almost certainly lacks the name recognition of both her foes, though she did enter the race with an endorsement from Texans for Lawsuit Reform, which the Texas Tribune describes as “the powerful tort reform group that supported Paxton for attorney general in the 2014 and 2018 general elections.” A primary runoff would take place if no one earns a majority of the vote in the first round.

Other Races

● Staten Island, NY Borough President: Former Rep. Vito Fossella’s lethargic comeback campaign picked up an endorsement over the weekend from Donald Trump ahead of Tuesday’s instant-runoff Republican primary.

Fossella, who retired from Congress in 2009 after the public learned about his second family, faces two intra-party opponents: New York City Councilman Steven Matteo, who has the backing of the borough’s Republican Party and a number of police unions, and former borough party chair Leticia Remauro, who has the Conservative Party in her corner. Four Democrats are also competing for an office that has been in GOP hands since the 1989 election.